Forex PAMM vs. Auto Trading (EA) [Comparison!! ]
Success with forex is not easy. In fact, more than 90% of traders are losing.
Anyone who visits this page …
There may be many people who have such troubles.
If you can’t succeed in manual trading, you can use an automated trading system (EA: Expert Advisor) or leave the trade to other traders with PAMM.
This page explains in detail the advantages and disadvantages of EA and PAMM. It should be a good reference on whether to invest in EA or PAMM.
Actually I am trading using EA and PAMM. If you are interested, please check out the “My results page”.
Features of EA
What is EA?
EA (Expert advisor) is an automated trading system that runs on the MT4 terminal.
The EA will automatically determine entry and exit timing.
Cost to operate EA
The purchase price of EA depends on the thing, but most of them are 200USD-500USD.
EA can be purchased at “MQL5”, “FOREX STORE” or on its own sales site.
In addition, to operate EA, it is necessary to operate a computer with MT4 for 24 hours.
There are the following disadvantages when a home computer is operated for 24 hours.
Disadvantages of full PC operation
- If communication failure occurs due to power down or network malfunction, there is a risk that the EA will not move and large loss will occur.
- If you run your computer for 24 hours, your electricity bill will increase
- If PC is moved for 24 hours, the deterioration will be faster and replacement will be required sooner.
There are many disadvantages to running EA on your PC.
Therefore, to run EA, it is common to use a rental server called VPS (Virtual Private Server).
To use the rental server, a monthly fee of about 20USD to 40USD is required.
Are there any profitable EAs?
I have actually confirmed the performance of more than a few hundred EAs.
For your reference, I have created an “EA Review Article” for a famous EA.
Some EAs may continue to win, but if you want to use them, you need to be aware of the following weak points of EAs.
- An EA that uses single logic will give good results only within a certain period of time. However, there is a possibility of losing when the market movement changes.
- EA results vary greatly depending on the operating environment and settings. Therefore, the same result as the developer test may not be obtained. (Especially, the scalping EA is greatly affected by slippage, etc. The results vary greatly depending on the broker and VPS used.)
Although there are many anxiety factors, there are EAs that may continue to win.
Summary of EA
Disadvantages of EA
- It is a little difficult to prepare for operation. EA purchase, MT4 set, parameter setting, VPS rental, etc.
- The purchase cost is high.
- When using VPS, fixed monthly fee is incurred. If EA does not make profits that exceed the VPS fee, profits will be negative, so it is necessary to trade with a slightly larger fund volume.
- Especially in the case of the scalping EA, the result varies depending on the operating environment, so there is a risk that the result will not be known until it is used.
Advantages of EA
- You can customize the lot size and risk by adjusting the parameters yourself.
- All profits gained from trading are yours.
Compared to the PAMM account, which will be explained in detail later, automatic trading using EA is a little more difficult.
Features of PAMM
What is PAMM?
In PAMM, trading managers and investors can make a profit together.
The manager decides in advance the distribution of profits between himself and the investor.
After trading, if profits are generated, profits are distributed to managers and investors according to the distribution ratio.
Conversely, if loss occurs, it will be distributed to the manager and investors.
Costs of PAMM investment
Once you deposit into PAMM account, you just have to wait for the profit / loss to be allocated based on the manager’s trading results.
Profits are distributed to managers according to the profit distribution ratio, but it is a great advantage that no other costs or labor is required.
(Note that there is no fixed cost, but of course there is a risk of losing the funds you have deposited.)
Cost benefits of PAMM
- No need to purchase software like EA
- No fixed costs such as VPS rental fees
- No need for a PC for chart analysis and trading
- Just deposit money into PAMM account on your smartphone
- No need to set VPS & MT4
In this way, investment in PAMM takes less cost and effort than manual trading or system trading using EA.
Summary of PAMM
PAMM has some disadvantages, but I think the benefits are greater than EA.
Disadvantages of PAMM
- In the case of a PAMM-provided broker that does not display the trade history, it is difficult to verify the trading method. Even if the profit and loss graph looks good, it may actually use a very high-risk approach.
- Even if you make a withdrawal request, you cannot withdraw immediately. (In many cases, withdrawals can only be processed every 1 to 2 weeks in order to protect managers’ trading activities. This is because withdrawals that exceed the free margin cannot be made realistically while holding positions.)
- For better or worse, you can’t intervene your discretion in trading. The transaction is completely left to the judgment of the PAMM manager.
- There is no fixed cost or labor. Once you deposit, you don’t have to do anything. This is the biggest advantage of PAMM
- The results published by the broker are reflected directly in your account. So, it is possible to make investment decisions by predicting expected values from past results.
As a supplement to the second benefit, PAMM results do not differ by broker, account type (real or demo), VPS, etc. This is a huge advantage unlike EA.
In EA, the seller’s forward test shows good results, but when you actually use it, you may lose.
On the other hand, in PAMM, the results of managers and users are the same. (PAMM managers get rewards based on the profit share, but the transaction results are the same.)
Is there profitable PAMM?
I have invested in AccentForex’s PAMM service and have been profitable so far.
AccentForex is not a well-known broker. However, AccentForex’s PAMM service has many accounts with stable results.
Summary of comparison between PAMM and EA
Both PAMM and EA have advantages and disadvantages.
Compared with EA, PAMM does not require fixed costs or labor, and can be profitable.
On the other hand, EA has “interestingness” that allows you to customize the transaction yourself.
However, it is necessary to be prepared for the possibility of losing funds in all EA, PAMM, and manual trades.
Once we understand this risk, we need to invest money while verifying which method has the highest expectations.
If you invest in a good PAMM manager or EA, you might see significant profits in the future.